Time to Drive? (Part 3)

 

 

The first two installments of this three part series addressed various steering wheel hand positions and by whom those positions were advocated. This article addresses why each of the driving methods are espoused. Once again, for this discussion, we will assume that the automobile is a non-commercial vehicle.

Historically the hand position 10 and 2 has been the norm. However, more recently, a growing belief in the 9 and 3 (8 and 4) hand position is gaining momentum based on the extent of a growing type of injury to the upper extremities.

Hulke (SAE 970493) found that in 540 crashes with steering wheel airbag deployment, 38% of the drivers sustained upper extremity injuries. In 18 of the crashes, the drivers sustained upper extremity fractures, all directly due to either the deploying airbag or the airbag module cover. In 12 of the crashes, the fractures were caused by the upper extremity being flung into vehicle structures.

The research performed by Atkinson (SAE 2002-01-0022) shows that the forearm was the most commonly fractured upper extremity. Airbag deployment is associated with an increase of 2 to 3 times in the proportion of forearm fractures versus no airbag deployment. His research concluded that "airbag deployment increases the risk of forearm fracture as a proportion of all upper extremity fractures and that females are at an increased risk of such injury."

How does this relate to hand positions? Quite simply, utilization of the 9 and 3 (8 and 4) hand position, when used in the "shuffle" steering method, appears to keep the upper extremities more clear of the airbag during activation. Additionally, if the upper extremities are thrown about due to an airbag deployment, they are less likely to be flung into the driver’s face.

Finally, according to Dr. Smock (www.airbagonoff.com), motor vehicle operators should be aware that although airbags can significantly reduce the severity of injuries sustained in frontal collisions the module cover has the potential to inflict serious, even fatal, injuries.

-Winthrop P. Smith, PhD.

 

 

Reprinted from The Reconstructor, Newsletter of Boster, Kobayashi & Associates, Summer 2004. 


Experts  -  "The Reconstructor"  -  Graphics & Animations  -  Fee Schedule  -  Memberships
Home  -  Site Guide  -  Contact Information


925.447.6495 info@boster-kobayashi.com
Copyright  2005 Boster-Kobayashi.com   All rights reserved.  Webmaster